"I've... actually never tried to bake one." That would definitely be unique. Maybe someday he'd give it a shot, just for fun.

He shook his head, a little embarrassed. "I can play a few guitar chords, but I never had the time or the resources to really learn. Seemed like fun, though."

"I'm sorry the band thing didn't work out for you." His smile softened a little. "Well, maybe not completely sorry since I probably wouldn't have met you if you were a big record star."